Porter, S.; Millar, N.; Coyne, C.

Crop improvement can enhance food security, but side effects, such as trade-offs between valuable agronomic traits, are common. Likewise, fertilisation helps ensure high yields, but can devalue mutualisms with soil microbes that would otherwise be essential for nutrient acquisition. If the need for nutritional mutualisms is reduced in crops, mutualisms could be disrupted by selection relaxation or allocation trade-offs. Thus, crops could achieve high yields in spite of, or because of, disruption of nutritional mutualisms. Alternatively, the highest-yielding plants might flourish because they maximise nutrient acquisition from both symbionts and the soil. Here, enhanced mutualism could evolve over the course of agricultural crop improvement. To investigate whether high yields in cultivars and wild accessions are negatively or positively genetically correlated with outcomes in the legume-rhizobia mutualism, we measured whether yield and symbiosis traits trade-off or are positively genetically correlated among cultivars and wild accessions. We also tested whether this relationship differs between accessions released before or after 1950. We measured genetic correlations between yield and mutualism traits in 87 domesticated pea (Pisum sativum) accessions in a common garden agricultural field across three years. Seed yield and N2 fixation (%Ndfa) were positively genetically correlated. While N fixation was more strongly predictive of yield in the pre-1950 accessions than the post-1950 accessions, the underlying positive genetic correlation between the traits did not differ between the groups. The positive genetic correlation between yield and N2 fixation indicates that selection to increase yields has maintained or increased the benefits of the rhizobial mutualism in pea. Our findings predict that breeding to increase yield may continue to produce pea cultivars that get a greater proportion of their N from rhizobia, enhancing symbiotic mutualism and reducing the proportion of N supplied by fertilisation.