Quiroga-Carmona, M.; Urquizo, J. H.; Bautista, N. M.; DElia, G.; Storz, J.

Aim: to characterize the evolution of climatic niches during the diversification of the Phyllotis darwini species group, in order to assess the extent to which divergences involved in radiation were associated with patterns of conservatism or divergence of climatic niches, and whether the differentiation found among climatic niches correlated with species phylogenetic relationships. Location: south-central Andes, surrounding lowlands, and Patagonia, South America. Methods: species climatic niches were characterized by sampling contemporaneous precipitation and temperature conditions across occurrence locations and entire distributional ranges. Climatic niches were analyzed and modeled using multivariate statistics (PCA, PERMANOVA), a maximum entropy-based algorithm, and novel methods developed to explore levels of differentiation (niche overlap test) and divergence (niche divergence test) between realized and fundamental niches. Comparative phylogenetic methods were applied using a time-calibrated phylogeny and integrating climate niche data to estimate ancestral environmental niches within geographic and environmental spaces. Results: comparisons revealed low levels of climatic niche overlap, both among species' realized niches and among their fundamental niches, suggesting high levels of niche differentiation during the diversification of Phyllotis species. Quantifications of niche overlap further showed that observed differences among species lay primarily in the multidimensional nature of climatic niches, as unidimensional quantifications exhibited higher levels of overlap. Evolved differences among species' climatic niches were better fitted to a Brownian motion model of evolution, but lacked phylogenetic signal and showed no significant association with species' phylogenetic distances. Main conclusions: low levels of differentiation between ancestral climatic niches suggest that the early radiation of species in the Phyllotis darwini species group was promoted by geographic isolation, whereas the more recent diversification of extant species was accompanied by climatic niche differentiation, possibly involving local adaptation to regional ecoclimatic changes associated with Quaternary glacial cycles. The spatial separation of sister species, the complete divergence of their climatic niches, and the lack of phylogenetic signal in niche differences suggest a scenario of diversification in which divergences were prompted by the spatial isolation, but also by the divergent selection exerted by regional climatic differences.